TheAgencyAwardYouSawIsMeaningless
Most agency awards are purchased. Entry fees, networking requirements, and judging opacity mean awards reflect marketing budgets, not client outcomes. They are credentials for the credulous.
How Agency Awards Actually Work
The typical agency award process:
- Pay entry fee (£500 to £2,000+ per submission)
- Submit case study with your own claimed results
- Judges (often industry peers) review submissions
- Winners announced at gala dinner (more fees to attend)
- Winner logos available for marketing
"The agencies that win the most awards are often the agencies with the largest award entry budgets, not the best client results."
The Pay-to-Play Reality
The Economics of Awards
- • Award programmes need revenue to exist
- • Entry fees are the primary revenue source
- • More entries = more revenue = lower standards
- • Shortlisting many agencies maximises event attendance
- • Creating many categories means more winners, more entries
What to Ask About Any Award
- "Was there an entry fee?"
If yes, it is pay-to-play. The fee does not determine the winner, but it determines who enters. - "Who judged it?"
Peer judging often means competitors evaluating each other. Conflicts of interest abound. - "Were results independently verified?"
Most awards accept self-reported metrics. No one checks if they are true. - "How many categories exist?"
Award programmes with 50+ categories exist to maximise winners and fees, not recognise excellence.
Awards That Might Actually Mean Something
Some awards have more rigorous processes:
- • Google Premier Partner status (based on actual performance data)
- • Platform certifications requiring exam passing
- • Industry body recognition with independent auditing
- • Client testimonials on independent review platforms
Even these should be questioned. But they involve external verification rather than just submission fees.
Better Ways to Evaluate Agencies
Ask for Client References
Not testimonials on their website. Actual names and numbers of people you can call.
Request Specific Case Studies
Ask for examples in your industry, at your scale, with your challenges. Generic case studies are marketing.
Ask About Their Failures
An agency that claims 100% success is lying. Ask when things went wrong and what they learned.
Our Position on Awards
We have won awards. We are not pretending otherwise. But we do not lead with them because we know what they represent: a marketing budget line item, not a measure of client outcomes.
Judge us by our methodology, our client references, and our willingness to be transparent about limitations. That is harder to fake than a trophy.
Stay informed
Get our latest insights on Google Ads strategy delivered to your inbox. No fluff, no spam, just honest thinking.
Unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.